Pin it
Get ready for delicious comfort. Big chunks of juicy beef and mushrooms swim in a rich, cozy sauce, all tucked into a buttery, crisp crust. It's one of those unfussy dishes that hits the spot and really fills you up. It's no wonder this old favorite sticks around — take one bite and you’ll get it.
This pie showed up in our house during a freezing spell one winter. We needed something extra warm and satisfying. Once it started baking, the smell filled the place, and everyone started asking when we could finally eat. When we finally sat down, nobody said a word — they just dug in. Now, anytime it’s chilly, it’s our go-to Sunday meal.
Effortless Ingredient Guide
- Liquid Stars: Red wine brings tang and extra zip, while beef broth gives everything a deep, complex flavor that ties it together.
- Aromatics: Toss in onion and garlic early — they lay down all the rich, savory foundation your stew needs.
- Mushrooms: Any fresh ones you like work. They make the beef taste even meatier and round out the filling.
- Picking Beef: Grab chuck roast because its fatty bits and chewy parts soften up beautifully with slow, gentle cooking.
Fun in the Kitchen
- Final Touches:
- Use an egg wash on top so your pie comes out looking shiny and golden, then bake it off till the filling is bubbling.
- Pie Time:
- Let the mix cool off, then settle it into your pastry-lined dish.
- Long Simmer:
- Add some herbs and salt or pepper, drop the heat to just a simmer, and don't forget to get rid of those bay leaves.
- Add the Liquids:
- Carefully pour in your wine and broth, stirring so you don't end up with lumps in your sauce.
- Thicken It Up:
- Toss in your flour after the meat and veggies, which helps the filling set and get that nice, thick gravy.
- Veggies Join:
- Once the beef is browned, add mushrooms and carrots. Stir just now and then to keep things from sticking.
- Brown the Meat:
- Boost the temp a bit higher and brown the beef chunks a few at a time. This keeps them from steaming instead of getting that good crust.
- Start With Flavors:
- Heat some oil in a big Dutch oven on medium, and sauté your onion for about five minutes, then add in the garlic.
Pin it
When I first made this for my dad, he tried it and instantly said it was just like the ones his grandma made. Sitting with him, hearing old stories while he enjoyed every bite, made it way more special than just what ended up on the plate.
Tasty Pairings
This cozy dish is perfect as the main event at your table. Go for steamed veggies like peas or broccoli tossed in butter to lighten things up. Spoon some of that luscious gravy over a heap of creamy mashed potatoes for the ultimate comfort dinner.
Easy Customization
Switch it up however you want. Trade the beef for ground lamb and add mint if you're after a shepherd's pie feel. Make little single servings in ramekins, or sneak in different seasonal veggies to boost flavor.
Best Leftovers
This pie keeps really well. Pop leftovers in a sealed container in the fridge for three days max. Warm up in the oven at 325°F, using some foil on top to stop extra browning. Or, freeze the whole thing (unbaked) and it’ll last for months.
Pin it
There’s something amazing about taking a golden pie out of the oven and setting it right in the middle of the table. The mix of flaky pastry, juicy beef, and that deep, rich sauce doesn’t just fill you up. It really feels good, too.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is it cool to fix the pie filling sooner?
- Go ahead and whip up the filling a couple days before. Stash it in the fridge—the longer it sits, the bolder it tastes when it’s time to bake.
- → What’s a quick swap for red wine here?
- If you’re out of red wine, just pour in more beef broth. For an extra kick, a splash of balsamic vinegar (1-2 tablespoons) with the broth works great too.
- → Can I stash this beef mushroom pie in the freezer?
- Definitely! Freeze either way—before or after baking. If it’s raw, wait on the egg wash till baking time. Cook from frozen, just tack on another 15–20 minutes.
- → What should I put on the side?
- This goes awesome with a pile of mashed potatoes, steamed veggies, or just a handful of fresh greens. Cranberry sauce or some pickles make things lively too.
- → How do I tell when the beef pie’s baked through?
- You’re good once the pastry’s browned and you see the filling bubbling up through the little cut-holes. If the edges get dark too soon, just lay some foil over ‘em.