Pin it
Give plain brioche a glow-up with this unforgettable morning dish that fuses creamy custard with the dreamy vibe of crème brûlée. Every bite hits you with the combo of caramel underneath and soft, rich bread—it's like a gourmet brunch at home.
The first Christmas I made this for breakfast, everyone thought I'd picked it up from a boutique bakery. Now it's the go-to for our holiday mornings—the smell of vanilla and caramel drifts through the house and pulls everyone to the table.
Irresistible Key Ingredients
- Brioche Bread: Fluffy, super buttery, and perfect for letting all the custard soak in but still staying rich and soft.
- European Butter: Extra creamy and rich, it melts down for ultra-smooth caramel sauce.
- Dark Brown Sugar: With lots of molasses, adds deep caramel flavor and a chewy bite.
- Pure Maple Syrup: Grade A dark syrup brings that earthy, deep sweetness.
- Fresh Eggs: Farm eggs with those golden yolks give the custard its dreamy, silky feel and help everything hold together.
- Premium Vanilla: Madagascar vanilla packs in the cozy, naturally sweet vibes and ties all the flavors together.
How To Nail This Breakfast
- Magic Chill Time:
- Pop the dish in the fridge overnight, covered up tight. Let those flavors come together and the bread get fully soaked for 8-12 hours.
- Easy Custard:
- Crack your eggs and whisk until smooth, pour in half-and-half, then stir in vanilla and a pinch of salt. This makes a smooth, rich custard for your bread.
- Brioche Basics:
- Cut the brioche into chunky pieces. Let it sit out to get a little dry—that way it'll soak up more goodness. Place slices in the pan, overlapping just a bit for full coverage.
- Creamy Pour:
- Drizzle your custard slowly over the bread so every piece gets a nice soak. There's no need to mash it down, just a gentle press is plenty.
- Caramel Starting Point:
- Melt butter gently on medium. When it's ready, add brown sugar and maple syrup, letting them blend into a smooth, dark caramel. Pour it right into your baking dish before it sets.
Pin it
Brunch experiments showed me that a day-old loaf is ideal for this. One Easter, I realized letting it sit at room temp before baking stops raw spots and gives you fluffy insides every time.
Serving With Style
Spoon it out straight from the pan, letting caramel sauce spill onto the plates. Add some fresh berries and mint to make it look fancy. Warm up your maple syrup and pour it from a pretty pitcher so everyone can add their own.
Fun Twists to Try
Mix it up by using croissants or challah instead of brioche. Zest some orange into the custard for a citrusy hit. Want to go bold? Spread a bit of cream cheese in the middle for a special treat.
Simple Storage
If you're not baking it yet, just wrap tight and keep in the fridge for up to a day. When it's already cooked, cover leftovers and reheat one piece at a time in a 350°F oven until they’re steamy again.
Pin it
After making this French toast so many times for family events, it’s turned into what we always do to celebrate. Something about those few ingredients and this foolproof method just makes magic. Whether you serve it up for holidays or relaxed weekend brunch, you’ll see how special a simple breakfast can actually be.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is sandwich bread okay if I don't have brioche?
- Sure, you can use it, but brioche or challah have more flavor and hold up better when they soak overnight.
- → Don't have half-and-half?
- Mix whole milk with heavy cream, or just stick to milk if you want it lighter.
- → Can I prep this more than a night before?
- Don't let it soak for over 12 hours or it'll get mushy. Six to eight hours is just right.
- → Why let it sit until it isn't cold before baking?
- If you take the chill off first, everything bakes evenly and your dish won't crack from the sudden heat.
- → How do I tell if it's baked through?
- Caramel at the sides should bubble, the top should look golden, and a knife poked in the middle should come out clean.