Mushroom Swiss Burger

Level up your burger night with a super juicy, tasty Mushroom Swiss treat. Sink your teeth into a tender beef patty, stacked high with buttery sautéed mushrooms and onions, and loaded with melty Swiss cheese. The savory, rich flavors pack a punch in every bite. All tucked between a soft toasted brioche bun with the fixings you love, this at-home meal brings restaurant vibes with shockingly little effort.

I whipped these up for my brother, who's a burger snob. After just one bite, he said it beat any burger he'd paid for at a fancy place. The real magic? Giving mushrooms the time to get super brown and flavorful—they're the perfect match for gooey Swiss. Now, every family hangout features these burgers.

Tasty Components

• Steak seasoning: Gives the beef a punch of flavor, mixing salt, pepper, and savory spices so your patty needs no extra work
• Brioche buns: Soft, slightly sweet, and buttery, these buns hold up well and make each bite extra good
• Swiss cheese: Smooth and nutty, it melts right over the patty and mushrooms for creamy goodness
• Worcestershire sauce: Boosts that deep, savory taste and ties together beef and mushrooms
• Fresh garlic: Cooks down to mellow, punchy flavor in your mushroom mix
• Onions: Get golden and sweet as they caramelize next to the mushrooms
• Cremini mushrooms: Earthy and rich, they make for a hearty, tasty topping
• Ground beef: Pick an 80/20 blend for juicy burgers that stay tender and never dry out

How to Make It

Mushroom blend:

Start by melting butter in a pan over medium heat until bubbly (don’t let it brown). Toss in onion and mushrooms. Let them sit for a minute or two before stirring so they start getting some golden edges. Keep cooking, stirring now and then, about 8-10 minutes until they’re shrunken and toasty. Sprinkle in minced garlic at the end so it doesn’t burn. Right at the end, splash in Worcestershire and season with salt and pepper.

Making patties:

Add steak seasoning and Worcestershire to your ground beef in a bowl. Use your hands gently to combine—don’t squish it too much or it’ll get tough. Split it into four balls, then make patties a bit wider than your buns (they shrink). Push your thumb into the center of each patty to keep them flat as they cook.

Cooking burgers:

Fire up your pan or grill to medium-high and get it nice and hot. Toss the patties on—don’t smash them down, or you’ll lose juices. Let cook about 3-5 minutes, then flip once. Watch for little beads of juice on top if you like medium. Top each with Swiss at the end and cover for a minute if you want extra melt.

Toasting buns:

As burgers finish, butter the inside of each bun. Put them cut side down on a hot pan or grill area and toast for 30-60 seconds until golden. This step keeps buns from getting soggy and adds a yummy crunch.

Put it together:

Layer your hot, cheesy burger right on the bottom bun. Pile mushrooms and onions over the cheese so it gets nice and messy. Add extras if you want—lettuce, tomato, any sauces. Cap it all with the top bun and press down a bit to hold everything in place.

Pin it

I love mixing up what mushrooms I use for this. The one time I combined mushrooms from the farmers market—chanterelles and oyster—I swear it tasted almost truffley. My husband asks for this meal a couple times a month now, and even my nephew (totally against mushrooms before) is a fan, as long as they’re browned just right.

Serving Ideas

Pair these stacked burgers with golden fries or sweet potato fries tossed in a little sea salt. If you want something lighter, a peppery arugula salad with a zippy lemon dressing is awesome with the rich burger. For crunch, homemade slaw brings in some tang. Or make it a true treat with beer-battered onion rings that match the sweet onion flavor in the patties.

Fun Twists

Switch up your mushrooms for a new vibe—try hearty portobellos for a chunky layer or mild oysters for a lighter touch. Want to swap cheeses? Melt some gouda, sharp cheddar, or creamy brie over the patty. Toss in fresh thyme with your mushrooms for French flair, or add rosemary for a fresh, woodsy kick that’s awesome with beef.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What's the top mushroom pick for this burger?

Cremini and baby bella mushrooms really shine because they're hearty and full of flavor. White mushrooms are okay too but taste milder. Mix it up for even more fun flavors.

→ How do I keep burger patties from getting tiny?

Shape your patties so they're bigger than the buns, then push a little dip in the middle with your thumb. This makes them stay chunky when cooked. Don't handle the meat too much or they'll get tough.

→ Can I whip up the mushrooms before time?

Yep! Get the mushroom mix ready up to two days early and stash it in the fridge. Warm it up in a pan when you're ready to eat. It makes busy days easier.

→ What's the trick for melty Swiss cheese?

Throw the cheese on your patties about a minute before they're done, then cover with a lid or metal bowl. The steam helps melt the cheese just right.

→ What goes well with Mushroom Swiss Burgers?

Fries, sweet potato fries, or onion rings are classic. Want something lighter? Try a salad, coleslaw, or some roasted veggies. Don't skip a pickle spear for a little tang beside all that cheesy goodness.