Cowboy Butter Spread

This cowboy butter adds a punch of rich flavors to every dish, turning simple meals into something special with its mix of herbs, spices, and smooth butter.

I originally whipped up this cowboy butter for a garden cookout when I needed something extra to go with our grilled steaks. The butter was gone before the main dish, and these days my family asks for it with everything from morning toast to fancy fish dinners.

Ingredients

• Unsalted butter: the base that lets you manage salt and guarantees the most vibrant taste
• Coarse Dijon mustard: gives a tang and richness that standard mustard can't deliver
• Fresh chives: offers subtle onion taste and lovely green bits through the butter
• Fresh parsley: brings freshness and color while cutting the butter's richness
• Fresh thyme: contributes earthiness that pairs perfectly with chicken and beef
• Minced garlic: adds key savory elements, pick hard bulbs with snug skin for best flavor
• Lemon juice: balances the richness with a zesty kick that lifts all other tastes
• Paprika: brings mild smoky sweetness and beautiful coloring
• Kosher salt: boosts all flavors with bigger crystals that give better flavor control
• Black pepper: supplies needed warmth that works with the butter without being too strong
• Cayenne pepper: creates a smooth heat that grows slowly, always use fresh cayenne
• Crushed red pepper flakes: gives texture and eye appeal with bits of spicy flavor

Step-by-Step Instructions

Combine ingredients:

Put softened butter in a medium bowl making sure it's completely soft but not melted for best mixing. Throw in the Dijon mustard, chopped chives, chopped parsley, thyme leaves, minced garlic, lemon juice, paprika, kosher salt, black pepper, cayenne pepper, and red pepper flakes. Don't worry if it looks a bit separated at first, it'll come together as you mix.

Mix thoroughly:

Grab a rubber spatula or wooden spoon and blend everything together, making sure to clean the sides of the bowl as you go. Keep folding and mixing until you can't see any plain butter and the herbs are spread out evenly. Your butter should look uniform with little green and red specks throughout.

Shape or melt:

For solid butter, dump the mix onto plastic wrap and roll it into a log about 1.5 inches thick. Wrap it tight, twist the ends to close it up. Chill until hard, at least 2 hours. For a sauce version, put it in a microwave-safe bowl and heat for 20 seconds at a time, giving it a stir between each until it's fully melted but not hot or breaking apart.

Store properly:

Put it in an airtight container if it's a dip or keep it wrapped if it's a log. Keep in the fridge up to 5 days, though it tastes best in the first 2 3 days. Let the log sit out for 10 minutes before cutting so it's easier to slice.

Pin it

Thyme might just be the key ingredient here. I found this out when I made some without it one night after my herb garden ran low. The change was obvious my husband quickly noticed something was missing. The woodsy, slightly flowery hints of fresh thyme build a base that makes this truly cowboy butter instead of just herbed butter.

Serving Suggestions

Cowboy butter makes almost anything taste better. For an amazing steak, put a slice of the firm butter on a hot grilled ribeye and watch it melt into every crack. The herbs and spices make the beef taste even better while the butter creates a quick sauce.

If you love seafood, try melting the cowboy butter and brushing it on grilled shrimp or lobster tails right before they're done. The butter makes a tasty coating while adding great flavors without drowning out their gentle taste.

My everyday favorite has to be just spreading it on warm bread. Something wonderful happens when cowboy butter melts on a hot toasted baguette or fresh dinner rolls. The mix of crunchy bread and tasty butter makes a starter good enough for special events but easy enough for regular dinners.

Storage Tips

Though cowboy butter will last in the fridge up to 5 days, it tastes best during the first 48 hours. Keep the butter log wrapped tight in plastic, then covered with foil to stop any fridge smells from getting in.

To keep it longer, you can freeze cowboy butter for up to three months. I like to cut the log into rounds before freezing, then place them on parchment paper until they're hard. Move the frozen butter pieces to a freezer bag so you can thaw just what you need instead of the whole log.

If you made the melted dipping version, store it in a glass container with a snug lid. The butter will harden when chilled, so you'll need to warm it gently before using it again. I've found that glass containers keep plastic tastes from mixing with the subtle flavors.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What can I do with Cowboy Butter?

Spread it on fresh bread, melt and use as a dipping sauce with meats, or enhance your sides with its rich flavor.

→ What’s the best way to store it?

Pop it into an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 5 days. For long-term storage, roll it into a log and freeze.

→ How do I roll it into a log?

Spoon the butter mixture onto some plastic wrap, roll it up tightly, twist the ends, and chill for at least a couple of hours.

→ Can the spice level be changed?

Definitely! Add more paprika or garlic for extra flavor, or dial down the cayenne and skip the flakes for something milder.

→ What foods go best with it?

It’s amazing with grilled meats, roasted veggies, seafood, or spread over warm bread and baked potatoes.