Pin it
Soft, chewy white chocolate chip M&M pudding cookies pack a colorful punch with candy pieces and smooth white chocolate chunks. The trick to their incredible softness? A box of instant vanilla pudding mix that gives them that melt-in-your-mouth feel and boosts the vanilla flavor. Everyone grabs another one without thinking twice! These pretty treats work great with holiday-colored M&Ms, but they're a hit any time you make them.
I stumbled on the pudding mix trick after trying an incredibly soft cookie at a community bake sale. Once I got the secret from the baker, I played around with different mix-ins until I landed on this white chocolate and M&M combo. What still blows me away is how fresh these cookies stay compared to regular ones—they somehow don't get stale even after days of snacking. Whenever I bring a batch to parties, they're always gone first, and people can't figure out what makes the texture so special. The pudding mix has turned into my go-to cookie hack that never fails to wow everyone.
What You'll Need
- Salted butter: Gives a yummy taste and helps create a soft cookie.
- Brown sugar: Makes cookies chewy and adds moisture.
- Granulated sugar: Creates the right sweetness and crispy edges.
- Instant vanilla pudding mix: Keeps everything soft and adds more vanilla goodness.
- All-purpose flour: Forms the base without making cookies tough.
- White chocolate chips: Brings in creamy bits and sweet vanilla flavor.
- M&Ms: Adds fun colors, a bit of crunch, and chocolate taste.
Making The Cookies
- Get Ready:
- Heat your oven to 375°F (190°C) and put parchment on your cookie sheets.
- Mix The Base:
- Whip softened butter with brown sugar, white sugar, and the pudding powder until it looks fluffy.
- Wet Stuff:
- Beat in eggs one by one, then pour in the vanilla extract.
- Dry Stuff:
- Slowly mix in flour and baking soda just until everything comes together.
- Add The Good Parts:
- Stir in white chocolate chips and M&Ms, but save some for the tops.
- Make Cookies:
- Roll dough into balls (about 2 tablespoons each) and put them two inches apart.
- Watch The Clock:
- Bake them for exactly 10 minutes until the edges look set but middles seem a bit underdone.
- Let Them Rest:
- Keep cookies on the hot pan for 10 minutes before moving to a cooling rack.
Pin it
My first try with pudding cookies taught me something crucial about timing. I kept them in until they looked totally done, but ended up with cookies that got too firm once they cooled. Now I'm super strict about pulling them out at exactly 10 minutes when they still look a bit gooey. This tiny change turned good cookies into amazing ones that stay soft for days. Another game-changer was pushing extra M&Ms into the tops before baking. This simple trick makes them look way more appetizing and draws people in before they even take a bite.
Ways To Enjoy
Put them on a plate with some brownies and chocolate-covered strawberries. Make ice cream sandwiches with them or wrap them in cute bags as gifts for friends.
Different Takes
Switch up the M&M colors for holidays and add stuff like mint flavoring, cinnamon, or dried fruits depending on the season.
Keeping Them Fresh
They'll stay good in a sealed container for about five days. You can also freeze the unbaked dough balls for up to three months and bake them whenever you want fresh cookies.
Pin it
These white chocolate chip M&M pudding cookies have become my trademark at bake sales, holiday parties, and in care packages. What started as just playing around with pudding mix turned into the treat everyone knows me for. They're so soft and work for so many different events, plus they're easy enough to make even when I'm super busy. The bright M&Ms catch everyone's eye right away, but that amazing melt-in-your-mouth feel is what makes people grab seconds and thirds. It's funny how something as simple as a box of instant pudding can turn regular cookies into something everyone talks about.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What makes adding pudding mix important for this recipe?
- The mix keeps these cookies extra tender and prevents them from becoming dry. It adds a slight flavor boost too, making the cookies fresher for longer.
- → Are there other pudding flavors I can try?
- Sure! Vanilla is classic, but chocolate, butterscotch, or even cheesecake pudding can switch up the flavor for a fun twist.
- → Why leave cookies to cool on the baking sheet?
- Removing them too soon stops extra setting time, leaving a softer center. Letting them sit on the sheet finishes the texture balance perfectly.
- → Can I swap out the white chocolate and M&Ms for something else?
- Of course! Mix it up with nuts, dark chocolate, dried fruits, or festive candies to suit your preferences or the season.
- → How do I freeze the cookie dough properly?
- Shape into dough balls, freeze them flat on a tray, then store in a bag. Bake directly from frozen, adding just a couple extra minutes to bake time.